Meaningless ‘Security Surge’ for One Day Only – on Amtrak

Policeguns1b Operation RailSafe will see a 'law enforcement surge' on Amtrak routes on Friday this week.  Uniformed police will be 'a visible presence on national transit routes', and the exercise is said to involve all the local police agencies along the Amtrak routes in the exercise.  Details here.

Is this a hurried response to the currently heightened fears of terrorist attacks in Britain and Europe, and an urgent attempt to protect against a specific threat against Amtrak?  Uh – no.  A senior DHS official said it is a long-planned exercise which is not connected in any way to the terror threat in Europe.

So what is the point of this exercise?  It certainly won't catch any terrorists, because it is being publicized in advance.  It comes from nowhere, involves a lot of hassle for travelers and overtime costs for law enforcement agencies, then disappears again the next day with nothing to show for it.

Any terrorists planning to do nefarious deeds on an Amtrak train would simply have to wait 24 hours, and do whatever they were planning on Saturday.  The worst case would be the train they wanted to attack doesn't run every day and they might have to wait two or three days.

Of course, any terrorist who wanted to attack Amtrak in this country would need his head examined, anyway.  Amtrak is not a close part of the social or services infrastructure of the country, and sadly for most of us is an irrelevancy – unlike air travel, unlike sports stadiums, unlike shopping malls, unlike theaters, schools, hospitals, amusement parks and all manner of other vulnerable places where lots of people are crowded into small places.

Four thoughts and one conclusion :

1.  Is this the most vulnerable part of our nation, most likely to suffer a disruptive terrorist attack at present?

And, if it is indeed the most vulnerable, in what way will this one day exercise make Amtrak less vulnerable to attack the next day, and into the future?

2. Is this the best use of our police?  Are there no actual real crimes that need to be detected or prevented anywhere along the Amtrak routes?

Why not spend the tens (possibly even hundreds) of thousands of man hours going into this exercise on real policing?  How about 'the war on drugs' (whatever happened to that, anyway – did we win or lose)?  How about catching some burglars or prowlers?  How about doing something about the gang problems in our inner cities?  Or if that is too hard, why not go arrest some drunk drivers (or simpler still, ticket motorists for exceeding the speed limit by a trivial amount)?  Or go around city streets fining people jaywalking and parking on expired parking meters?

3.   Is this the best use of our taxpayer dollars?

For sure there'll be overtime, shift allowances, meals, transportation costs, and who knows what else associated with this exercise.  If the claim that every police agency along Amtrak routes will be involved is true (and that's a huge number of city, county, specialized, state and federal agencies), this will be an enormous exercise; best case scenario merely taking away tens/hundreds of thousands of hours from 'real policing' work and more likely scenario adding up to millions of dollars in above the line costs as well.

Why not spend the millions of dollars this exercise will cost on repairing some of the Amtrak carriages that are currently inoperable – that would have a greater net benefit to Amtrak riders than a day of security theater.

Or why not pay down the deficit a bit?  Or allocate the money to other more pressing issues with more direct outcomes?

4.  What about the cost and inconvenience to law abiding American citizens simply wishing to peacefully travel on Amtrak.

Did anyone ask them if they wished to join in the fun and games?  Did anyone ask them if they wished to stand in line waiting to have their belongings searched, if they wanted to have to show ID to get on and off the train, and so on?  Or is our inconvenience not a factor to be considered when planning pointless exercises that serve no clear purpose?

Conclusion :  There is no sense in this regrettable waste of manpower and money.  There will be no positive outcome and no benefit.

All this does is condition us one small step further to having our ordinary day to day lives interrupted and interfered with by machine gun toting battle fatigue wearing paramilitary police who have no part or place in a free society, one small step further to obediently showing photo ID without question or complaint whenever asked, one small step further to accepting restrictions on what we do, where we go, and how we do it, one small step further to passively accepting the government's demand to know all about us, where we are, what we are doing, with who, and why.


Leave a Reply

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top

Free Weekly Emailed Newsletter

Usually weekly, since 2001, we publish a roundup of travel and travel related technology developments, and often a feature article too.

You’ll stay up to date with the latest and greatest (and cautioned about the worst) developments.  You’ll get information to help you choose and become a better informed traveler and consumer, how to best use new technologies, and at times, will learn of things that might entertain, amuse, annoy or even outrage you.

We’re very politically incorrect and love to point out the unrebutted hypocrisies and unfairnesses out there.

This is all entirely free (but you’re welcome to voluntarily contribute!), and should you wish to, easy to cancel.

We’re not about to spam you any which way and as you can see, we don’t ask for any information except your email address and how often you want to receive our newsletters.

Newsletter Signup - Welcome!

Thanks for choosing to receive our newsletters.  We hope you’ll enjoy them and become a long-term reader, and maybe on occasion, add comments and thoughts of your own to the newsletters and articles we publish.

We’ll send you a confirmation email some time in the next few days to confirm your email address, and when you reply to that, you’ll then be on the list.

All the very best for now, and welcome to the growing “Travel Insider family”.